THE CARING COUCH Seat 8: Melanie
Melanie, 40, has everything success is supposed to bring. But betrayal in marriage, deception at work and a traumatic medical experience have shattered her trust. Convinced she was born to be deceived, she discovers that three terrible chapters need not define her entire story.
The Woman Who Stopped Believing in Good Fortune Melanie arrives eleven minutes early. She wears a beautifully tailored cream jacket, dark trousers and the kind of watch that suggests she has never been late for anything important. Her hair is immaculate. So is her makeup. She examines the couch before sitting down. Melanie: Is this where I'm supposed to have some sort of emotional breakthrough? Counsellor: It's where you're supposed to sit. Melanie: Excellent. Low expectations. I like that. (She sits, crosses her legs and places her handbag beside her. Her phone lights up. She turns it face down.) Counsellor: What brought you here, Melanie? Melanie: My lawyer. Counsellor: Your lawyer suggested counselling? Melanie: One of them. I have three now. Marriage, employment and medical negligence. I'm practically keeping a small legal economy alive. Counsellor: That's a lot to be dealing with. Melanie: Apparently, I collect disasters. Some women collect handbags. I collect people who lie to me. (She smiles. It doesn't last.) Counsellor: Tell me about that. Melanie: Which one? The husband who treated our marriage like an unsecured credit facility? The company that suddenly forgot what my bonus agreement said? Or the hospital that turned a routine diagnostic procedure into something I now have to explain to strangers in legal offices? Counsellor: Whichever one feels closest today. Melanie: They're all close. That's the problem. There's nowhere I can go where one of them isn't waiting. (A pause.) Melanie: I'm forty. I run a major account division at an advertising firm. I manage people, budgets, clients who think changing a logo from blue to slightly darker blue is a strategic revolution. I make decisions worth millions. I'm good at what I do. Very good. Counsellor: You sound proud of that. Melanie: I was. Counsellor: Was? Melanie: You know what's funny? Competence doesn't protect you from being made a fool of. My husband was moving money around for years. Loans, investments, obligations I knew nothing about. I discovered some of it through a bank notification. Imagine that. Years of marriage and a bank message tells you more about your husband than he does. And when I confronted him, he said he was protecting me. Protecting me! (She laughs sharply.) Melanie: I would've preferred the danger. Counsellor: What hurt most about discovering it? Melanie: That I defended him. To friends. To my family. Even to myself. There were signs. There always are, apparently. Everyone becomes a detective after the crime. And now we're separating, and every conversation is about documents, liabilities, accounts, who knew what, who owes whom. Nobody asks what happened to the marriage. Actually, I don't ask anymore either. Counsellor: Do you miss him? (Melanie looks towards the window.) Melanie: I miss the man I thought I married. I'm not sure that answers your question. Counsellor: It does. (Silence.) Melanie: And then work. I spent four years building a division that was practically on life support when I inherited it. We turned it around. New clients, record billings, awards. I missed holidays. Anniversaries. My mother's birthday twice. My contract had a performance bonus. When the numbers came in, suddenly there were conditions nobody had mentioned before. A revised interpretation. Some committee. A committee! Do you know how much dishonesty can fit inside that word? Counsellor: You felt cheated. Melanie: I was cheated. There's a difference. Counsellor: You're right. I shouldn't reduce what you're describing to a feeling. Melanie: Thank you. (She adjusts her sleeve.) Melanie: The strange thing is, I could probably earn that money somewhere else. I have options. Recruiters call me. I know people. But that's not the point. I believed them. I believed that if I did exceptional work, the agreement would mean something. Apparently, agreements are just decorative until someone has to honour them. Counsellor: And the hospital? (Her expression changes. For the first time, she doesn't answer immediately.) Melanie: That one's different. I went in for a small diagnostic investigation. Something routine, or that's how it was explained to me. I asked questions. I signed papers. I trusted the professionals. What followed was nothing like what I thought I'd agreed to. More procedures. Complications. Pain. Conflicting explanations. I kept asking what had happened, and nobody seemed willing to give me a straight answer. One doctor said one thing. Another contradicted him. The hospital gave me a beautifully worded letter that said almost nothing. Eventually, I found another specialist. Then another. Now there's a lawsuit. Counsellor: How are you physically? Melanie: Better than I was. But I don't feel safe going to a doctor anymore. I question everything. Every prescription, every test, every signature. I used to be able to walk into a hospital and believe someone knew what they were doing. Now I hear a medical explanation and wonder what isn't being said. Counsellor: That sounds exhausting. Melanie: It is. And the worst part? I don't even know if I'm being sensible or paranoid anymore. (A long silence.) Melanie: Three different worlds. Marriage. Work. Medicine. Different people. Different promises. Same result. At some point you have to wonder what the common factor is. Counsellor: What do you think it is? Melanie: Me. (She looks directly at the counsellor.) Melanie: That's the answer, isn't it? I'm the common factor. I'm smart enough to negotiate a multinational campaign, but apparently not smart enough to know when somebody is lying to my face. Maybe there's something in my destiny. Maybe some people are born lucky and some are born to be deceived. Counsellor: Do you believe that? Melanie: I didn't. I used to think people made their own luck. Now I think some of us are just walking around with targets on our backs. Counsellor: And when you look back, do you see only the betrayals? Melanie: Recently? Yes. Counsellor: What about everything that happened between them? Melanie: What do you mean? Counsellor: Forty years is a long time. You've mentioned three terrible experiences. I'm wondering what else exists in those forty years. Melanie: Plenty of things. Counsellor: Good things? Melanie: Of course. Counsellor: Do they still count? (Melanie opens her mouth, then closes it.) Melanie: That's an annoyingly good question. Counsellor: You don't have to answer it now. Melanie: No. I should. I've had a good life in many ways. Opportunities. Friends. Travel. A career I genuinely loved. People who've been kind to me. I know I'm fortunate. But lately, when something good happens, I immediately wonder what it's going to cost. Someone compliments my work and I wonder what they want. Someone offers help and I wonder what the catch is. A man asks me to dinner and I wonder what he's hiding. Even when nothing is wrong, I'm waiting for something to be wrong. Counsellor: It sounds as though the betrayals haven't just changed how you see those people. They've changed how you anticipate the future. Melanie: Exactly. I don't trust good news anymore. (She says it quietly, as if the sentence surprises her.) Melanie: That's what I've become. A woman who doesn't trust good news. Counsellor: Is that who you've become, or how you've been protecting yourself? Melanie: Does it matter? Counsellor: I think it might. One sounds permanent. The other might change. (She looks down at her hands.) Melanie: I hate that I'm like this. I used to be fun. I was the woman who booked a weekend in another country because the weather looked nice. I danced at weddings. I bought ridiculous shoes. I believed people when they said they loved me. I wasn't stupid. I was happy. And now I spend my evenings reading legal documents and searching medical terminology. My friends say I should take a holiday. Where am I supposed to go? Somewhere without my own head? Counsellor: What do you miss most about that earlier Melanie? Melanie: The ease. Not having to inspect everything. Not feeling like life is a contract with hidden clauses. (She rubs her eyes carefully, mindful of her makeup.) Melanie: Do you think I'm naive? Counsellor: For trusting people? Melanie: For trusting the wrong people. Counsellor: I don't know enough about every decision you made to judge them. But trusting a spouse, expecting an employer to honour an agreement, and relying on medical professionals are not unreasonable things to do. Melanie: Yet here we are. Counsellor: Yes. Here we are. And none of that means your hurt isn't real. Or that there weren't things you might do differently in the future. But there's a distinction between learning from what happened and deciding you were born for it to happen. Melanie: You're saying I shouldn't blame myself. Counsellor: I'm saying we shouldn't confuse a pattern of painful events with proof of a destiny. Melanie: It feels like proof. Counsellor: I believe you. (A pause.) Counsellor: Can I ask you something? Melanie: You've been doing it for forty minutes. Counsellor: Fair enough. (She gives a small smile.) Counsellor: You've spent a lot of time telling me what other people have taken from you. What do you think they haven't taken? Melanie: My money, what's left of it. Counsellor: Anything else? Melanie: My career. Technically. Counsellor: Anything that isn't an asset? (She considers this.) Melanie: My ability. Nobody can take that away. Counsellor: What else? Melanie: My sense of humour, apparently. Though it's become rather expensive. (A brief laugh.) Melanie: My friends. Most of them. My independence. My taste in shoes. Counsellor: That's quite a list. Melanie: It's a start. (She sits back.) Melanie: But what am I supposed to do? Go back out and trust everybody? Counsellor: No. Melanie: Good. Because I wasn't going to. Counsellor: You don't have to trust everyone. You don't even have to trust anyone quickly. You can ask questions. Check documents. Get second opinions. Set boundaries. Take your time. Those are all reasonable things. Melanie: So become suspicious professionally. Counsellor: Become discerning. Melanie: Advertising people love that word. Counsellor: Is it a bad one? Melanie: No. Just overused. (Silence.) Melanie: You know what frightens me? That even if all three cases work out — the separation, the bonus, the hospital — I still won't feel like myself. I'll have the money, or the apology, or the judgment. And I'll still be waiting for the next disaster. Counsellor: That is something we can work on here. Not by convincing you the world is safe, but by helping you find ways to live without having to predict every danger. Melanie: And what if it happens again? Counsellor: Something might. I can't promise otherwise. Melanie: Finally. Someone who doesn't make promises. Counsellor: I can tell you this much: you've responded to some very difficult circumstances. You've sought help. You've taken action where you believed you were wronged. And you're here, asking what happens next. That tells me the part of you that wants a life beyond all this is still present. (Melanie is silent for a while.) Melanie: I hadn't thought of it like that. I thought I was here because I was falling apart. Counsellor: Maybe both things can be true. You can be struggling and still be moving towards something. Melanie: I don't feel like I'm moving. Counsellor: You came here. Melanie: Eleven minutes early. Counsellor: You mentioned that. (She laughs. This time it reaches her eyes.) Melanie: I suppose I'm quite good at showing up. Counsellor: It seems so. (A long pause.) Melanie: Can I tell you something ridiculous? Counsellor: Of course. Melanie: Last week, a friend invited me to her birthday dinner. I said no. Told her I had work. I didn't. I stayed home reviewing a medical report I'd already read six times. And while I was reading it, I kept thinking how unfair everything was. Then I saw photographs of the dinner the next morning. Everyone laughing. Terrible cake. My friend wearing this hideous green dress. And I was angry. Not with anyone. With myself. Because there was an entire evening happening somewhere, and I chose to sit alone with people who'd already hurt me. Counsellor: What do you make of that now? (She looks at the floor.) Melanie: I think they've taken enough of my time. Counsellor: That sounds important. Melanie: I don't want to spend the rest of my life making them the main characters. (Silence.) Melanie: The cases aren't going away. I know that. I still want accountability. I still want what's owed to me. And I still want to know exactly what happened at that hospital. Counsellor: You can pursue those things. Melanie: But perhaps I don't have to live inside them every hour of the day. Counsellor: Perhaps not. (She picks up her phone, checks the screen and places it back down.) Melanie: My friend's having lunch on Sunday. I said I'd think about it. Counsellor: What would you like to do? Melanie: Go. Counsellor: Then maybe that's something to consider. Melanie: She'll ask how I am. Counsellor: What would you like to say? Melanie: That I'm a work in progress. No, that's awful. Sounds like a corporate rebranding exercise. (She smiles.) Melanie: Maybe I'll just tell her I'm glad to see her. Counsellor: That sounds like enough. (Melanie stands. She picks up her handbag, then pauses.) Melanie: I came here thinking there must be something terribly wrong with my destiny. Counsellor: And now? Melanie: I don't know what I believe about destiny anymore. But I think I've been treating three terrible chapters as though they were the whole book. (She glances towards the couch.) Melanie: They aren't, are they? Counsellor: I don't think you want them to be. Melanie: No. I really don't. (She walks towards the door, then turns.) Melanie: By the way, this couch is surprisingly comfortable. Counsellor: I'm glad. Melanie: Don't let that go to your head. And for the record, I'm still suing the hospital. Counsellor: I didn't ask you to stop. Melanie: Good. (She opens the door.) Melanie: Maybe I'll buy those ridiculous shoes I've been looking at. Counsellor: Do you need them? Melanie: Absolutely not. (She smiles.) Melanie: That's rather the point. The door closes gently. The couch remains where it is. For the first time in a long while, Melanie has somewhere to go that isn't a lawyer's office, a hospital or a meeting room. And she is looking forward to it. — The Caring Couch doesn't rewrite the past, settle disputes or promise that people will never disappoint us again. It offers a place where pain doesn't have to become identity, and where a difficult chapter is allowed to end without being mistaken for the entire story. Seat 8 is now empty. There is still room for the next story.